Heretic

Hugh Grant

Mr. Reed

Sophie Thatcher

Sister Barnes

Chloe East

Sister Paxton

Topher Grace

Elder Kennedy

Elle Young

Prophet

Julie Lynn-Mortensen

Pedestrian

Haylie Hansen

Teenager

Elle McKinnon

Teenager

?

Hanna Huffman

Teenager

Anesha Bailey

Neighbor

Miguel Castillo

Neighbor

Stephanie Lavigne

Believer

Wendy Gorling

Disciple

River Codack

Missionary #1 (uncredited)

Carolyn Adair

Driver with Car (uncredited)