Peter and Vandy

Jason Ritter

Peter

Jess Weixler

Vandy

Jesse L. Martin

Paul

Tracie Thoms

Marissa

Noah Bean

Andrew

David Rasche

Alan

?

Bobby Aiello

Male Bartender

Bruce Altman

Dad

Dana Eskelson

Emma

Kristina Klebe

Michelle

Lawrence Michael Levine

Mike

Zak Orth

Keith

Maryann Plunkett

Mom

Gregg Prosser

Wedding Guest