Neverland

?

Rick Sparks

Peter Pan

?

Melany Bell

Wendy Darling

Wil Wheaton

John Darling

?

Marcus Reynaga

Michael Darling

David Jahn

George Darling

?

Deborah Quayle

Mary Darling

Kari Wahlgren

Tinker Bell

Joey

Nana

?

Stephanie Kirchen

Liza

?

Gary Kelley

James Hook

Scott Mechlowicz

Sam "Smee" Smiegel

?

Ryan Patrick Kelly

Tootles

?

Ian Mantha

Slightly

?

Eli Swanson

Curly

?

Zach Cole

Nibs