Mothman

Jewel Staite

Katharine

Connor Fox

Derek

Susie Abromeit

Mindy

?

Michael Aills

Jared

Matty Ferraro

Casey

?

Jerry Leggio

Frank

T.W. Leshner

Richard

Jess Sylvia

Sally

?

Alex Hardee

Jamie

?

Arvilla Riddick

Elderly Woman

Wallace Merck

Mayor Dinkins

Douglas M. Griffin

Policeman

?

Kennon Kepper

Young Boy

Lucy Faust

Young Boy's Mother

?

Sam Schulak

Scrawny Teenager