My Girlfriend's Boyfriend

Alyssa Milano

Jesse Young

Christopher Gorham

Ethan Reed

Michael Landes

Troy Parker

Tom Lenk

David Young

Beau Bridges

Uncle Logan

Carol Kane

Barbara

Heather Stephens

Sarah, Ethan's Sister

David Nibley

Bill, Sarah’s Husband

?

Hannah McFarland

Hayley

?

Chase Little

Connor

?

Adam McFarland

Adam

Tayva Patch

Aunt Linda

Chantel Flanders

Catie

Kelly Packard

Suzy

?

Stephen Carey

Matthew, Boy in Window