The Bachelor Next Door

Haylie Duff

Alex

Michael Welch

Donnie

Brittany Underwood

Sage

Tyler Johnson

Johnny

Sarah Davenport

Allison

Caia Coley

Kaya

Preeti Desai

Jennifer Green

Kim Estes

Detective

?

Steven Bruns

Gavin

Blaise Brooks

Receptionist

David Hill

Police Officer