Most Likely to Murder

Madison McLaughlin

Casey

Heather McComb

Laura

Bayley Corman

Reagan

Trevor Stines

Sean

Ingrid Rogers

Deborah

Ava Allan

Hailey

Kara Royster

Taylor

Ashlee Füss

Clair

Fallon Smythe

Daphne

Brendan McCarthy

Harlen

?

Joseph Lim Kim

Mr. Lavalier

Peter Donahue

Vance

?

Olivia Handwerk

Hiker

?

Taylor LeBaugh

Kyle