Girl Most Likely

Kristen Wiig

Imogene

Annette Bening

Zelda

Matt Dillon

George

Darren Criss

Lee

Christopher Fitzgerald

Ralph

June Diane Raphael

Dara

Natasha Lyonne

Allyson

Bob Balaban

Maxwell

Sydney Lucas

Little Imogene

Jimmy Palumbo

Doorman Joe

Michelle Morgan

Georgina

Mickey Sumner

Hannah

?

Elizabeth Inghram

Sloane

Brian Petsos

Peter Van Woodsen

Murray Bartlett

James Whitney