The Three Stooges

Sean Hayes

Larry

Will Sasso

Curly

Chris Diamantopoulos

Moe

Jane Lynch

Mother Superior

Sofía Vergara

Lydia

Jennifer Hudson

Sister Rosemary

Craig Bierko

Mac

Stephen Collins

Mr. Harter

Larry David

Sister Mary-Mengele

Kirby Heyborne

Teddy

Carly Craig

Mrs. Harter

Kate Upton

Sister Bernice

Marianne Leone Cooper

Sister Ricarda

Brian Doyle-Murray

Monsignor Ratliffe

Mike Sorrentino

The Situation