You're So Cupid

Lauren Holly

Audrey Valentine

Brian Krause

Daniel Valentine

Jeremy Sumpter

Connor

Caitlin E.J. Meyer

Lily Valentine

Danielle Chuchran

Emma Valentine

Amanda Gallo

Ashley

Melise

Megan

Chad Hively

Elliot

?

Jessica Jackson

Piper

Susan Phelan

Mrs. Porter

Zack Phifer

Principal Barlow

Logan Rogan

Marvin

Nikola Clark

Rita

Dayne Rockwood

Tyler

?

Michael James Brown

Pizza Delivery Guy