Meet Cute

Kaley Cuoco

Sheila

Pete Davidson

Gary

Deborah S. Craig

June

Sierra Fisk

Sandra

Wesley Holloway

Young Gary

Rock Kohli

Amit

Hari Nef

Chai

Kevin Corrigan

Phil the Bartender

Rebecca Schull

Gertrude

Pat Bowie

Ethel

Josy Soriano

Tatiana

?

Andrew Stevens Purdy

Teen Gary

?

Mia Matysiak

Young Sheila

Matthew Wolf

Soccer Announcer (voice)